Communal accommodation not legal vindication
The articles in this issue are centred on the difficulties – and possible resolutions – of the renewed standoffs over a contested Orange ‘walk’ and the resulting nationalist opposition.
The starting point was a procedural shortcoming in the initial banning of a regularly renewed application to parade by the Portadown Orangemen [of District Lodge No 1 – this is where it all started 200 years ago in 1796]. That opened the way for a series of legal adjudications culminating in an ill-judged last minute reversal of the initial ban by the Parades Commission and the formal authorisation of a much reduced parade. This reversion to the conflicts of the 1990s can still be avoided by joint action by the PSNI Chief Constable and the Secretary of State. The police have so far sensibly refrained from using their powers to clear the road of ‘unlawful obstructers’ and have only sought details of relatively minor offences. And the local population is enjoying a spell of quite peaceful campaigning. But the leaders of the main unionist and nationalist parties have stepped in to assert the very different principles of the ‘rule of law’ and communal human rights.
This is not the way in which the Good Friday Agreement was achieved: not by legal proceedings or majority voting but by ‘sufficient consensus’ in long-drawn out negotiations hosted by the British and Irish governments with Senator Mitchell as a neutral chair. These same procedures need to be revived not only on the Druncree/Garvaghy Road standoff but also on the equally fraught issues of Border Polls on Irish unification, which Feargal Cochrane thinks is best left to economic developments; and also the wide range of ‘legacy’ issues – not by majority voting or strict legal adjudication on contested incidents but by the shared Protestant and Catholic values of loving your neighbour and forgiving their trespasses, as argued by Tom Hadden and Paul Nolan in their pleas for prioritising reconciliation over legal action.
The article on the need for new opinion polling on options for the future, based on Fortnight’s ‘tolerability’ surveys’ in 1997, likewise suggests a way forward based on mutual accommodation, as in Malachi O’Doherty’s account of the Belfast fleadh, rather than the assertion of incompatible legal and constitutional positions.
View Issue 503